Ok, so you know the actual story behind the lyrics of By You already, because you all have read New Moon. I wanted to tell you a little about how the song came about, though.
The first two Twilight-inspired songs that I wrote were Twilight Hour and Jacob Black. After completing Jacob Black I really wanted to write a song with a time signature of ¾ rather than 4/4, so I started toying with chord progressions.
Any Chevelle fans out there? Well, if you’ve heard of them before then you’re most certainly familiar with one of their bigger songs called The Red. It’s a very driven, melodic rock song with some really vast dynamic changes. So, if I had to pick a song that musically inspired By You then it would have to be that one. I wanted By You to feature some of the same major changes in dynamics throughout the song, too.
I actually had the chorus to the song written before I wrote everything else. The rest of the song kind of radiated outward from the line “And the chill of your touch, Never thought I’d miss the cold so much.” I always wanted it to be kind of a retrospective song, too. At the end of the song Bella is back in Edward’s arms looking back at everything she had been through leading up to that point.
Its an emotional song so I always wanted the chorus to a huge “wall of sound” that smacks the listener in the face. The word “chill” in the chorus is belted out on top of heavy distorted guitars to help listeners feel what Bella had been missing in her life. Even back on Twilight Hour I tried to convey that same emotion, but without the luxury of drums, electric guitars, and other production values.
Anyway, as a rocker at heart, By You is one of my favorite songs on the record. It was meant to speak to everyone who has ever had a hole in their chest. Whether or not the holes are filled the way you expect them to be or not, the void is always temporary in the end.
Mitch